top of page
A hand adds colorful sprinkles to frosted cupcakes, capturing a playful, finishing touch to the sweet treats at Butter Baked

Rooted in Love.
Baked with Purpose.

Founded right here in Seminole, FL, we’re a small, heart-led bakery bringing handcrafted cookies and cakes to our neighbors—one celebration at a time. We may be new, but our mission is timeless: create treats that feel like home and memories that last.

Ericka McAvaddy enjoys a bite of her signature tall cake, savoring the sweet reward of her homemade creation in the kitchen.

Pastry Chef & Owner 

With Butter Baked Cookies + Cakes, Ericka McAvaddy set out to share her love for baking with the world, offering not just delicious treats but also affordable, homemade cakes for birthdays and weddings. She’s committed to providing the same thoughtful, high-quality baked goods to all her customers, no matter their budget.

 

When she’s not in the kitchen, Ericka is an avid runner, embracing the balance of staying active while nurturing her creativity through baking. Our motto—Crave • Indulge • Smile—captures her goal to bring happiness and satisfaction with every bite, making each occasion a little sweeter.

229_adelacobakery_030722.jpg
  • Do you offer shipping or delivery?
    We do not ship. Single tiered cakes are not available for delivery. Wedding cakes and large orders require delivery. The delivery fee is a flat rate of $20.00 if the delivery is within a 25 mile radius of zip code 33772.
  • Can you make a children’s character-theme cake?
    Yes, but they are limited and the starting price is 175+. We do not use fondant.
  • Where will I pick up my cake?
    Seminole, Florida 33772 (Full address will be provided once full payment is received)
  • Do you require a retainer?
    Yes, we require a 50% non-refundable retainer to hold the date for celebration cakes. Wedding cakes there is a 25% non-refundable retainer to hold the date.
  • How far in advance should I place my order?
    Minimum of 2 WEEKS notice, but as soon as possible as our availability is limited
  • Do you offer vegan cakes?
    At this time we do not offer vegan cakes or allergy free cakes. We do not serve anyone if you have a nut allergy or dairy allergy.
  • Do you offer cake tastings?
    Yes we do offer cake tastings. The price is $50. You will be able to pick 5 of our standard or wedding cake flavors.
  • How do I cut the cake?
    Please see the cake short video below to learn wedge, slab, or geometric cutting techniques (each yield a different number of pieces):
  • Are your cakes, cupcakes, or cookies gluten free?
    At this time we do not offer gluten free cakes, cupcakes, or cookies.

Ready to Make Your Sweet Vision a Reality?

Whether you’re dreaming up the perfect party centerpiece or planning something extra special “just because,” we’d love to bake it happen.


Fill out our quick inquiry form to get started, we’ll be in touch soon with a custom quote made just for you.

Have a Question or Thought First?

Not ready to order and have further questions, send us a message.

If you're requesting a quote, please use our Inquiry Form.

Pickup in
Seminole, FL 33772

Ask about delivery.

Picture of entrance for Butter Baked Cookies + Cakes
bottom of page