Small Batch ✦ Freshly Baked ✦ Nationwide Shipping ✦ Member Only Flavors ✦
Why You'll Love It
Fresh-baked cookies and cake-slices delivered to your door. Handcrafted in small batches and made to brighten your month.
-
A treat you’ll look forward to every month
-
Exclusive flavors you won’t find anywhere else
-
Perfect for gifting (or keeping for yourself!)
-
Baked with care, shipped with love
-
Pause or cancel anytime
Cookies
Soft, rich cookies designed to satisfy cravings and bring back that just-one-more-bite feeling.
Cake Slices
Layered cake and buttercream crafted for indulgence, packaged to enjoy anywhere.
Monthly Flavors
A rotating lineup inspired by the season – revealed first to club members.
Choose Your Monthly Treat Box
Cookies + cakes made to crave – pick your Butter Baked Club membership.
Cookie Club
35$Every monthA monthly box of 4 bakery-style cookies, crafted fresh and delivered to your door.- 4 Bakery-Style Cookies Per Month
- Curated Assorted Selection
- Rotating Seasonal & Signature Flavors
- Handmade in Small Batches
- Shipping Included - Always
- Sweetest Value
Cookie + Cake Club
65$Every monthBakery-style cookies and cake slices in signature square jars, delivered fresh each month.- 4 Bakery-Style Cookies Per Month
- 4 Cake Slices in Square Jars Per Month
- Curated Assorted Selection
- Rotating Seasonal & Signature Flavors
- Handmade in Small Batches
- Shipping Included - Always
Cake Club
48$Every monthA rotating selection of 4 cake slices in our signature square jars, delivered fresh each month.- 4 Cake Slices in Square Jars Per Month
- Curated Assorted Selection
- Rotating Seasonal & Signature Flavors
- Handmade in Small Batches
- Shipping Included - Always
Flavors rotate monthly and may repeat throughout the year. Subscription contents may vary based on seasonal availability. All items are made in a kitchen that handles common allergens. Subscriptions renew automatically each month and may be canceled at any time through your member portal. Orders are baked fresh and shipped monthly; delivery timing may vary. All sales are final once a purchase or renewal is completed.
No commitment – pause, skip, or cancel anytime.
How The Butter Baked Club Works
Join
Choose the club that fits your sweet tooth.
Anticipate
Each month brings a new mix of flavors.
Enjoy
We ship a sweet surprise right to you.
