Cookies + Cakes
Every order is handcrafted just for you, so we ask that you place your request at least 2 weeks in advance.
Take a peek below and start dreaming up your perfect treat.
We’ll bring the magic to life.
Pick-up available on weekends from 2-5 PM. Orders may be placed 14-180 days before your event. Please allow at least 14 days' notice.
Single Tier Celebration Cake
Round, Heart, or Sheet cake. Serves between 2-30.
Round - 5" (serves 6-8)
$100
Round - 6” (serves 10-12)
$125
Round - 7” (serves 15-20)
$135
Round - 8” (serves 25-30)
$145
Heart - 6" (serves 8)
$115
Heart - 8" (serves 18)
$135
Cake Styles
Classic Vintage
Two-Tone Vintage
Textured Cake
Two Tier Celebration Cake
Round, Square, and Heart. Serves 20-60.
Round - 4” top, 6” bottom (serves 20)
$145
Round - 5” top, 7” bottom (serves 26)
$195
Round - 6” top, 8” bottom (serves 32)
$225
Square - 4" top, 6" bottom (serves 20)
$375
Square - 6” top, 8” bottom (serves 32)
$480
Square - 8” top, 10” bottom (serves 50)
$550
Heart - 6" top, 8" bottom (serves 36)
$245
Heart - 8” top, 10” bottom (serves 60)
$325
Cake Styles
Classic Vintage
Two-Tone Vintage
Textured Cake
Three Tier Celebration Cake
Round. Serves 40-60. (Heart and Square shaped three tier cakes, please request a custom quote.)
Round - 4” top, 6” middle, 8” bottom
$325
Round - 6” top, 8” middle, 10” bottom
$400
Cake Shape
Round
Square
Single Tier Children's Theme Cake
Serves 6-12
Round - 5" (serves 6-8)
$125
Round - 6” (serves 10-12)
$180
Cake Flavors - Top Tier
Vanilla
Chocolate
Strawberry
Two Tier Children's Theme Cake
Serves 20-32
Round - 4” top, 6” bottom (serves 20)
$225
Round - 5” top, 7” bottom (serves 26)
$275
Round - 6” top, 8” bottom (serves 32)
$350
Cake Flavors - Top Tier
Vanilla
Chocolate
Strawberry
Celebration Cake Box
5" 4-Layer Cake + half-dozen Matching Cupcakes. Serves 26
Celebration Package
$150
1st Birthday Party Package
$295
Cake Styles
Classic Vintage
Two-Tone Vintage
Textured Cake
The Butter Baked Signature Tasting Experience
Cake. Cookies. The full Butter Baked moment. Meet our Signature Tasting Experience — because choosing your favorites should feel just as special as the celebration itself. Indulge in the best of both worlds with a curated tasting of our cakes and cookies, all beautifully packaged and ready to enjoy. Cake Tasting Includes: • Your choice of 3 flavors • Each flavor comes as a 4-inch, 2-layer mini cake • Designed to give you the full Butter Baked flavor experience Cookie Tasting Includes: • Your choice of 3 cookie flavors • Our signature large, bakery-style cookies Perfect for weddings, events, or simply treating yourself while deciding your favorites. Pricing: • Full Signature Experience (Cake + Cookies): $75 • Cake Tasting Only: $50 • Cookie Tasting Only: $35
Wedding Cake Tasting Box Cake and Cookies
$75
Cake Tasting Box Only
$50
Cookie Tasting Box Only
$35
Cake Flavors - Tasting Box (pick 3)
Vanilla Cake w/ Berry Compote Filling and Vanilla Buttercream
White Almond Cake w/ Raspberry Filling and Almond Buttercream
White Almond Cake w/ Coconut Filling and Almond Buttercream
Prices starting for half dozen cupcakes. Request a quote for custom orders.
Celebration Cupcakes
Half Dozen
$25
Dozen
$35
Cake Flavors - Top Tier
Vanilla
Chocolate
Strawberry
Lux Cupcakes
Perfect for birthdays, anniversaries and more. Add a fondant cupcake topper to make it custom. Price is per dozen
$55
Cake Flavors - Top Tier
Vanilla
Chocolate
Strawberry
Floral Cupcakes
Floral themed cupcakes made out buttercream. Price is per dozen
$65
Cake Flavors - Top Tier
Vanilla
Chocolate
Strawberry
Standard flavors. Prices starting for half dozen. Request a quote for custom flavors.
Cookies and Cream Cookies
Half and Full Dozen
Half Dozen
$25
Dozen
$35
Double Chocolate Cookies
Half and Full Dozen
Half Dozen
$25
Dozen
$35
Classic Chocolate Chip
Half and Full Dozen
Half Dozen
$25
Dozen
$35
Cookie Butter Cookie
Half and Full Dozen
Half Dozen
$25
Dozen
$35
Cookie Cakes
Round, Half and Full Sheet
Round - 6" Cookie Cake
$45
Round - 7" Cookie Cake
$55
Round - 8" Cookie Cake
$60
Half Sheet Cookie Cake
$75
Full Sheet Cookie Cake
$95
Cookie Flavors
S'Mores Chunky Cookie
Double Chocolate Chip
Classic Chocolate Chip
